best cookie scoop

Best Cookie Scoop to Round Off Your Perfect Recipe

Ian Mutuli
Updated on

Whether entertaining guests or making snacks for your little ones, shaping the dough by hand is pretty challenging. Of course, you can follow your perfect recipe to the letter, but the best cookie scoop can help you make evenly proportioned cookies. After all, you would not want frustrations pushing you to throw away the dough and go with already baked and perfectly round cookies.

You do not need to be a cookie-baking aficionado to recreate your grandmother's recipe to a tee. However, if you struggle with ensuring your delectables are evenly baked or sized, the options here will help you out. First, let us define this kitchen tool before diving into which ones to buy and how you can choose.

What is a Cookie Scoop?

A cookie scoop features a hemispherical design that includes a metal frame, a spring mechanism and a handle. The kitchen tool allows you to scoop cookie dough in equal proportions, while the release action lets you work quickly. If you frequently try out different cookie recipes, this handy tool will speed up the prep time.

Moreover, it is simple to remove any excess dough sticking on the scoop to ensure you get consistently sized cookies that will bake evenly. Afterward, you release the scoops and flatten them to your desired thickness. Hence, you can guarantee that presentation will not be the downfall of your cookies.

Why Should You Use a Cookie Scoop?

The texture and taste of cookies are some of the most important aspects of these wholesome snacks. However, if they come out oddly shaped and randomly sized, your delectables may not be as inviting. Likewise, the prep work for your favorite cookie recipes can be challenging if you cannot find a way of getting evenly-baked cookies that are also appealing. After all, your hands may not be as efficient in sizing equal proportions.

Furthermore, investing in cookie scoops does not mean that these kitchen tools will only come in handy when following specific recipes. For instance, you can use them for scooping ice cream, making melon balls, filling cupcakes, measuring out muffin proportions and even scooping meatballs. The versatility of cookie scoops ensures that you are covered whether you are making a fruit salad or firing up your oven for some pastries.

The promise of uniform cookies when using a dough scoop gives the final products a professional look. In addition, you can take your grandmother's recipe to the next level by using the kitchen tools to enhance their presentation. So if you want to make your snacking options stand out, cookie scoops are the way to go. Plus, you can check out which oven size will work for you to turn your hobby into a business.

Which is the best cookie scoop?

10 Options for the Best Cookie Scoop

1. Wilton Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop

Wilton Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop, Silver
  • All of your cookies will be almost the exact same size and shape...
  • Scoop with squeeze handles makes it easy to get evenly...
  • Spring handle for easy release
  • Color: Silver; Material: Stainless steel
  • 4 teaspoon capacity

The Wilton Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop features sturdy and durable construction, capable of ensuring that you can measure even the stickiest dough with ease. In addition, the silver finish gives it a high-quality look. Plus, it is ideal for making medium-sized cookies as it has a capacity of 4 teaspoons.

The Wilton is the best cookie scoop for uniform cookies since it ensures you get a consistent proportion every time. Also, it utilizes a spring handle that you squeeze and release to drop cookies with ease. Finally, you can wash it quickly with warm water and soap before and after using it. First, however, you need to rinse it out and dry it before each baking session.

Pros:

  • The cookie scoop ensures you get consistent results in proportions.
  • Handwashing is simple.
  • Stain and rust-resistant.
  • Simple squeeze and release operation.

Cons:

  • It isn't dishwasher safe.
  • The gears get stuck sometimes, and you need to force it open for release.
  • It is not ideal for cold cookie doughs or scooping ice cream.

2. OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop

OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop, Multicolor, Large
  • Ideal for scraping, chopping and gathering ingredients
  • Stainless steel blade features 1" markings for precise measuring
  • Broad, soft, non-slip handle absorbs pressure

The OXO Good Grips Large Cookie Scoop, made from high-quality stainless steel, will give you reliable service without deforming or breaking. In addition, it comes with rubberized handles for extra grip when you bake cookies with sticky, wet or oily hands. Thus, it will not slip off your hands when working with it.

Furthermore, this cookie scoop is comfortable to hold for long periods without causing much strain. Also, the heavy-duty spring action makes measuring the cookie dough pretty easy. Hence, this is the ideal kitchen tool for ensuring your cookies bake evenly while maintaining fairly equal proportions.

Pros:

  • The cookie scoops are dishwasher safe.
  • The cookie dough scoop guarantees uniform sizes.
  • Simple to use.
  • The rubberized handle enhances grip.

Cons:

  • It is not a chef-quality tool as the scooping system has some issues.
  • This cookie scooper is not the most durable on our list.
  • The spring-loaded handle may break down after numerous uses.

3. Solula 18/8 Stainless Steel Large Ice Scream Scoop Disher Melon Baller

Solula 18/8 Stainless Steel Large Ice Cream Scoop...
  • BUILT TO LAST -- This scoop is made of 18/8 stainless steel,...
  • SIZE - Capacity: 4 tablespoon / 60ml / 0.25cup. Bowl diameter: 2...
  • EASY TO USE - Heavy-duty spring action releases food by sliding...
  • COMFORTABLE DESIGN - The handle incorporates an ergonomic design,...
  • PERFECT FOR MULTIPLE USES - Ideal for use at home, in a...

The Solula Professional Cookie Scoop features an 18/8 stainless steel construction ideal for making large cookies, forming melon balls and as an ice cream scoop. In addition, the premium quality stainless steel has food-grade qualities making it safe and durable for baking sessions. Plus, it comes with a 5-year warranty.

The mirror polish of this quality cookie scoop adds an aesthetic touch to this versatile tool. In addition, this stainless steel scoop is easy to hold whether you use your right or left hand. Also, ergonomics is a critical feature of the handle that guarantees uniform baking of a large cookie batch without tiring quickly.

Pros:

  • 5-year warranty.
  • Rust and corrosion-resistant.
  • Ergonomically designed handle for left-and-right handed users.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Versatile.
  • Heavy-duty spring action ensures easy use.

Cons:

  • Durability concerns as some of them do not last long.
  • It is not ideal if you want a medium scoop.
  • A simple squeeze may not always work, and you may need more effort.
  • Getting dough onto the baking sheet can be tricky as it sticks to this kitchen tool.

4. JSDOIN Cookie Scoop Set 18/8

Sale
Cookie Scoop Set,JSDOIN Ice Cream Scoop Set, 3 PCS 18/8...
  • WITH ERGONOMIC TRIGGER, SAVE YOUR TIME -- A simple squeeze...
  • BUILT TO LAST - Always brand new! Different from other inferior...
  • beautifully rounded balls of ice cream, fruit, sorbet, melon...
  • DISHWASHER SAFE& 3 SIZES - The ice cream scoop set includes small...
  • ELEGENT KITCHEN GADGETS - Works great for creating balls of...

The JSDOIN Cookie Scoop Set with 18/8 stainless steel material offers unparalleled durability and safety when working with food. This product is resistant to chipping and discoloration, for starters, ensuring that it does not lose its shine after prolonged use. However, you need to hand wash it to maintain the mirror polish.

Whether you are looking for a large, small or medium cookie scoop, the versatility of this set ensures you do not need to buy another tool for your baking needs. Additionally, you can use it for ice cream, cupcakes, meatballs and muffins. And the mirror finish has non-stick qualities to make releasing dough onto the baking sheet a cinch.

Pros:

  • It is dishwasher safe, although the manufacturer recommends handwashing it.
  • Versatile.
  • 18/8 stainless steel for durability and safety.
  • Handle ideal for left or right-handed people.

Cons:

  • You need to handle it well to ensure it lasts long.
  • The blade does not do well with chilled cookie dough or hardened ice creams.

5. Norpro Stainless Steel Scoop

Sale
Norpro Stainless Steel Scoop, 25MM (.5 Tablespoon)
  • Measures: 7.5" x 2.25" x .75" / 19cm x 5.75cm x 2cm
  • Scoop: .5 Tbsp/.25oz/7.5ml/25mm/, approximately 140 scoops per...
  • Heavy-duty spring action releases food easily.
  • Ideal for scooping ice cream, scoop and drop cookie dough, use to...
  • Made of stainless steel with a high polished finish.

The Norpro Stainless Steel Scoop comes in three different sizes for you to choose from, depending on the food applications. However, you need to buy each size separately to employ the versatile uses. Still, the sturdy construction of the stainless steel cookie scoop and its heavy-duty spring action guarantee a long-lasting product.

Moreover, the sweeping mechanism with a hinge simplifies the scooping and release actions of the tool. Hence, you can make baking cookies more enjoyable and easy since you can let your little ones in on the fun. After all, the cookie scoop does not require a lot of effort to operate.

Pros:

  • The sweeping mechanism simplifies operation.
  • Releases easily to reduce the chances of you making a mess.
  • Versatile.
  • Long lifespan.
  • Cleaning is easy.

Cons:

  • The design leaves plenty to be desired, especially when scooping.
  • The gears are not the most durable.
  • The metal is pretty light and does not feel like heavy-duty stainless steel.

6. Prep Solutions Measuring Scoop

Prep Solutions by Progressive Measuring Scoop
  • The prep solutions by Progressive quick release cookie scoop...
  • The quick release sweeper portions out the perfect amount of...
  • It is also great for creating meatballs, melon balls and scooping...
  • This cookie scoop has a 1 1/2 tbsp. (.75oz/22ml) capacity
  • It is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning

Like the previous entry, the Prep Solutions Measuring Scoop comes in three sizes. Plus, the unique design ensures that you are covered when baking cookies in the house or scooping melon balls outdoors. After all, the stainless steel cookie scoop features a plastic handle for enhancing its versatility.

When working with ice creams, you will appreciate the plastic handle in the Prep Solutions cookie scoops. After all, the soft plastic does not conduct heat, so you will not have to feel the cold steel when operating it. Plus, you can let your children help prepare cookie dough as you do not need plenty of force to use it.

Pros:

  • A quick-release system ensures consistent sizes for cookies and ice cream.
  • Stainless steel parts are rust and corrosion-resistant.
  • Ergonomic handle.
  • Plastic on the handle enhances grip.

Cons:

  • It loosens up with continued use.
  • You need to buy the other sizes separately.
  • The plastic does not last long, especially when frequently scooping ice cream or chilled dough.

7. Fayomir Cookie Scoop Set

Fayomir Cookie Scoop Set - Small/1 Tablespoon, Medium/2...
  • INCLUDE 3 DIFFERENT SIZES, MULTIPLE USES - The cookie scoop set...
  • TOP QUALITY, MADE OF 18/8 STAINLESS STEEL - The cookie scoops for...
  • EFFICIENT TRIGGER SYSTEM, EASY TO USE - With innovative...
  • SAFE FOR FOOD, SUPER KITCHEN HELPER - Made of food-grade...
  • EASILY CLEAN, DISHWASHER SAFE - Hand wash and dishwasher is safe....

The Fayomir Cookie Scoop Set offers three different sizes at a super competitive price that ensures it caters to your baking and meal prep needs. Also, the 18/8 stainless steel material is extra thick on the handle and spoon ball. Thus, the food-grade construction is pretty durable compared to other entries in our recommendations.

The cog and ratchet system of the Fayomir Cookie Scoop Set makes it stand out as one of the simplest gadgets to use. In addition, the trigger is pretty responsive and lets you pick up and drop equal portions with ease. Plus, you can use it in the right or left hand, and it will still feel comfortable to hold.

Pros:

  • Food-grade 18/8 stainless steel material.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Stain, corrosion and rust-resistant parts.
  • Ambidextrous design.
  • The cog and ratchet system is pretty easy to use.
  • Thickened sections of the cookie scoop enhance its longevity.

Cons:

  • The spoon ball is not entirely non-stick.
  • Not the best for thick or chilled cookie batter.
  • The scraper warps after frequent uses.

8. SaeBye Large Cookie Scoop

Large Cookie Scoop, 5.4 Tbsp/ 2.7 OZ, 2.5 inch/ 63MM...
  • LARGE SIZE, BIG CAPACITY – The large cookie scoop is 2.5 inch/...
  • HIGH QUALITY, SELECTED 18/8 STAINLESS STEEL - The large cookie...
  • WITH ERGONOMIC TRIGGER, EASY TO USE - Due to the newly designed...
  • MULTIPLE USES, IDEAL KITCHEN TOOL - With large ice cream scoop...
  • CLEAN EASILY,DISHWASHER SAFE, ENVIRONMENTALLY FRIENDLY - The...

The SaeBye Cookie Scoop has powerful springs complemented by an efficient cog and ratchet system. The combination allows you to bake plenty of cookies without straining your hand or wrists in the process. Plus, it presses and releases smoothly for an easy baking experience.

The cookie scoop has a slightly thickened bowl and an innovative scratch chip. Additionally, the handle features an arch, making it comfortable to hold regardless of your dominant hand (left or right). Plus, the 100% recyclability of the product makes it safe for the environment.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Corrosion, stain and rust-resistant parts.
  • Recyclable.
  • The ergonomic trigger for smooth operation.
  • Food-grade 18/8 stainless steel scoop.

Cons:

  • You have to buy each size individually.
  • It feels flimsy.
  • The cookie scoop falls apart when dealing with hard batter or ice cream.

9. Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set

Sale
Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set - Cookie Scoops for Baking -...
  • MULTIPLE USES - 3 scoopers for ice cream, gelato, sorbet, cupcake...
  • HIGHEST QUALITY - Professional chef choice for baking tools. 18/8...
  • ERGONOMIC DESIGN - Disher glides easily without intense pressure...
  • BUILT TO LAST - Heavy duty. Won't pit, corrode or rust. Mirror...
  • PERFECT GIFTS - Lustrous scoops in plush velvet bags. Elegant...

The Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set is the perfect gift for a baking fanatic as it comes in an elegant gift box. In addition, the silver finish looks fantastic, and it is complemented by the 18/8 premium quality stainless steel construction. Thus, you do not have to worry about harmful substances in your food.

Furthermore, this cookie scoop is pretty durable as the heavy-duty stainless steel parts give you reliable functioning for years. In addition, the cog and ratchet mechanism ensures you can apply it to professional baking scenarios without straining your wrists and hands. Plus, you can use either hand while operating the cookie scoop.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Do not chip, corrode or rust easily.
  • Versatile.
  • It comes in a gift box.
  • It does not make a mess.

Cons:

  • It may get stuck when releasing or squeezing.
  • The full metal handle makes gripping challenging.

10. Homure H Cookie Scoop Set

Sale
Cookie Scoop Set - #60/1 Tbsp, 40/2 Tbsp, 20/ 3Tbsp - 3...
  • THERE SIZE SCOOP, #20, #40, #60 – The cookie scoops set of 3...
  • MADE OF 18/8 STAINLESS STEEL, PREMIUM SCOOP – The cookie scoops...
  • ERGONOMIC TRIGGER SYSTEM, EFFICIENT AND PRACTICAL – The cookie...
  • CLEAN EASILY, DISHWASHER SAFE – The portion scoops set are easy...
  • MULTIPURPOSE KITCHEN SCOOP – The tablespoon cookie scoop can be...

The versatility and simple operation of the Homure H Cookie Scoop Set give it an edge over the competition. The different sizes mean you are covered whether you are making truffles or Italian meatballs, for starters. Hence, you can follow your favorite recipes and forget worries over consistent proportions.

If you are handling chilled dough or ice creams, you can warm up the scoop bowl in warm water before using the product. Although the manufacturer claims it is a heavy-duty cookie scoop, it is best not to use it on really hard things to ensure durability. Still, the stainless steel build is pretty sturdy.

Pros:

  • Dishwasher safe.
  • 18/8 stainless steel build.
  • Versatile.
  • Thickened handle and spoon ball for durability.
  • Ambidextrous handling.

Cons:

  • There is a design flaw in the scoop bowl, and it always has dough leftover.
  • Handling may feel off as the thumb placement area is pretty narrow.

The Best Cookie Scoop Buyer’s Guide

a). Cookie Size

Depending on the cookie recipes you want to try out, the bake sizes may vary. Consequently, get a cookie dough scoop set if you intend to use your oven frequently. For instance, a large cookie scoop size can give you 4-inch snacks. On the other hand, if you want larger diameters, you may need ice cream scoops to measure out more cookie dough.

A medium-size scoop is pretty versatile and can serve you when you bake cookies, scoop melon balls for a fruit salad or measure ground beef for your meatballs when making pasta. In addition, you can expect to get 3-inch pastries since you they scoop about 1.5 cookie dough tablespoons. So whether you are hosting a small party or fixing snacks for relaxing, the medium size scoop will suffice.

Alternatively, a small scoop is terrific for making regular-sized cookies about 2 inches across. However, scooping cookie dough with these options could be time-consuming. Still, regardless of their size, cookie scoops will help ensure your snacks are evenly baked with consistent proportions.

b). Scoop Construction

Sticky cookie dough can be trick to handle | Ivan Rohovchenko

Image Source: Unsplash.com

Aside from ensuring your cookies bake evenly, you need to think about the materials making up the scoop to figure out their durability. Ideally, you will not be scooping dough and slamming it on the cookie tray to drop it. However, if you do not consider the construction, the kitchen tool can bend, rust or even break after a few baking sessions.

If you are frequently working with sticky dough, it is best to avoid plastic cookie scoops. These options can let you down when running them through the dough. In addition, they can bend or deform, making it difficult to get the right quantity without making a mess.

Look for high-quality stainless steel material for your cookie scoop, as they are guaranteed to last long. In addition, these variations are pretty strong and work well with even sticky dough. Plus, you can use them to scoop ice cream since they will not rust when exposed to moisture.

c). Handle Design

As mentioned above, working with sticky dough can be pretty challenging. However, the scenario can be a nightmare if the handle slips from your hands or does not allow you to grip effectively. Thus, check whether the cookie scoop is suitable for your hand size before buying it.

You will have two choices when it comes to the handle design of cookie scoops. For starters, single-block variations feature a trigger located at their necks. Although these types are not easy to use, fewer parts mean they will last long before developing problems.

On the other hand, double-block handles are pretty simple to use. In addition, they come with a spring release mechanism to scoop cookie dough quickly. Nevertheless, the two types are pretty similar, so choosing between them could boil down to personal preference.

Finally, prioritize ergonomic designs for the handle that allow right-and-left-handed people to hold them comfortably. In addition, a plastic or rubber coating on the handle could offer insulating properties while also enhancing the grip. Plus, you will not have to touch the bare metal or have it slip off if your hands are wet or oily.

d). Trigger Design

We have looked at how the handle design affects the type of trigger on cookie scoops, ultimately determining ease of use. For instance, a spring trigger may be challenging to use if you have plenty of dough to work with. After all, these variations require you to operate them with your hand and wrist, which can get tiring.

Similarly, a side trigger requires more effort from your thumb. If you are baking cookies to sell, the constant use will tire you out quickly. Alternatively, a cog and ratchet mechanism is the most simple to use. The design requires the least effort, and whether you are using it as an ice cream scoop or for cookie dough, the reduced strain makes the process quick.

e). Keeping it Clean

Working with dough means you are bound to make a mess as it will get all over your cookie scoop. Therefore, look for variations that are dishwasher safe to ease the cleaning process. For example, you can put a stainless steel cookie scoop in your dishwasher or clean it manually with ease. However, you may need to check the manufacturer's recommendations and care tips for your stainless steel cutlery and tools.

Moreover, the scooping bowl's surface could feature a non-stick quality which eases cleaning. Otherwise, you may need to learn how to unclog your sink if you have to wash dough down the drain constantly.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on the Best Cookie Scoops

1. What size scoop is best for cookies?

The vast majority of cookie recipes require about 1.5 tablespoons of dough per piece. Therefore, a medium cookie scoop is the safest option if you do not want to get a set. Still, recipes that use add-ons like chocolate chips or nuts may require larger kitchen tools for reasonable proportions.

2. Are cookie scoops worth it?

Measuring out cookie dough by hand can be messy and challenging to ensure evenly baked results. In addition, you may not be able to guarantee consistent sizes and shapes when following your favorite recipes. Cookie scoops help you avoid guessing and get professional results every time. Plus, they ease and quicken the baking process.


                                                                            Featured Image Source: Unsplash.com

Ian Mutuli

About the author

Ian Mutuli

Founder and Managing Editor of Archute. He is also a graduate architect from The University of Nairobi, Kenya.