8 Best Roaster Oven Reviews for Quality Cooking

Ian Mutuli
Updated on

Finding the best roaster oven that is worth your cash and gives you efficient service might seem difficult, but it is not unfeasible. Whether an apartment dweller or seasoned cook, you've often come across this appliance in the market or at any organized event, and probably you'd like to buy one for yourself.

Your electric roaster oven should be high-quality, like your affordable cookware, to meet your expectations. It could be a better alternative to conventional ovens even though it is small. This is probably the oven for you if you move around or have a small kitchen space.

The challenge may be which one is best. Roaster ovens vary in price, model, capacity, materials, and many other features in the market. Buying a pricy appliance won't necessarily mean the best service but going for a cheaper appliance is a risk you wouldn't want to take. So, average prices are safer.

When looking for the best roaster over, please stick to the purpose it is intended to serve. Then other quality determinants will fall into place. Below are some of the best roaster ovens we tested that you can use as a guide to get this high-quality, economical machine. But first, let us discuss what a roaster oven is.

What Is a Roaster Oven?

Image Credits:homedepot.com

A roaster oven is a tabletop electronic cooking device that roasts, cooks, and bakes food by evenly distributing heat throughout the cooking chamber. It is small compared to conventional ovens; hence they are handy for people with smaller kitchen spaces.

This easy-to-use appliance is designed with several interesting features that ease the roasting and save you time and energy. Additionally, they may vary in size and usage, but depending on your preference, any roaster oven will leave you satisfied. So get one or as many as possible and enjoy the services effortlessly.

1. Oster 22 Quart Roaster Oven With Basting Lid

Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid | 22 Qt,...
  • Electric roaster oven accommodates turkeys up to 26 pounds
  • Self basting lid continually recirculates moisture
  • Versatile electric roaster bakes, slow cooks, roasts, and serves
  • Dimensions: 23.3 L x 15.6 W x 11.8 H inches
  • Roasting pan and rack are removable for easy cleanup

If you are a seasoned cook looking for an appliance to add to your tools and are unsure of a roaster oven space, this roaster oven has a 22-quart capacity, big enough for your whole chicken and the side dishes. I am not recommending it just for its attractive oval shape and the stainless steel material it is made of. Still, its ability to cook quickly by retaining heat inside because of the self-basting lid is something that marvels me.

Image Credits: walmart.com

Oster roaster oven comes with an enamel-on steel roasting pan that did not just ease my cleaning but also evenly spread heat during cooking. Another add-on to its roasting space is the roasting rack that permits the baking of almost everything, so when I need just a bun or a whole birthday cake, the product caters to my needs.

It has 14 heat settings ranging from 150 to 450 degrees, regulated by a variable dial. Still, one thing that is not okay with me is its inadequate insulation, but this can be solved by applying extra care, especially when handling elements such as the lid that could get extremely hot. After all, you don't want to treat a burn from making your delicious dish.

An added advantage to this versatile roaster oven that gives me so much ease is the lightweight design and the handles that make it quite portable and easy to carry, so I can move it easily when cleaning my kitchen space. With all these useful features, this roaster oven is quite affordable and easy to maintain plus, what more would I love if not the retention of my food's flavor? This oven does just that.

To sum it up, I recommend this oven because it is economical. Moreover, as it serves me quality roasting and saves my energy and time.

Pros:

  • Regulated cooking, roasting, and baking speed
  • Removable roasting pan and rack for easy cleaning
  • Portable
  • Large space enough for a whole chicken
  • Self-basting lid

Cons:

  • Weak insulation
  • Large amounts of food can be overcooked
  • Eats up large kitchen space

2. Oster Roaster Oven With Self-Basting Lid 18 Quart

Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid, 18 Quart,...
  • 18-quart roaster oven roasts, bakes, and slow cooks and fits up...
  • Self-basting lid recirculates moisture for tender and delicious...
  • Saves 30% time and uses 36% less energy than a traditional oven
  • Removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan for fast, even heat...
  • Variable temperature control dial to set cooking temperature from...

This Oster roaster has a big, round, and self-basting lid; hence it is a time and energy saver compared to conventional ovens. Also, unlike the first Oster roaster oven, this one has a handy window that lets me watch what's cooking, roasting, or baking without opening the lid.

Image Credits: kohls.com

Regarding functionality and service, this Oster roaster is a banger. I can cook, bake, roast, and defrost in the same roaster. In addition, the Oster roaster has a dual cook system. So this product enables me to prepare 2 dishes at different temperatures simultaneously. That is time and energy saved.

The removable enamel-on steel pan and the rack doubles as the oven space. Some other great features I like most about this Oster 18 QT roaster are the adjustable thermostat, programmable timer, three cooking levels, 23-liter capacity, and electric grill oven that brings fresh tastes and lots of convenience to my kitchen.

On matters of safety, this Oster roaster is manufactured with a cool door; that is, the housing of the roaster oven remains cool. Its dark color makes it immune to stains and very easy to clean. Fortunately, this color also camouflages scratches, making my roaster oven look brand new even after a long period of use. It also has a safety switch and a blockade that protects accidental operations.

Pros:

  • Large cooking space for any occasion
  • It saves up to 36% energy compared to a traditional oven
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Temperature can be off

3. NESCO MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart

Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White
  • 18 quart capacity
  • Removable enamel cook well
  • Cool touch handles
  • Adjustable thermostat from 200 to 450 degrees
  • Ul approved

This 18 QT roaster can roast up to 22-pound turkey and is easy to use. So for a professional buffet, it is fit for any cooking, roasting, or baking.

Its chrome roasting rack is fitted with lift-out handles and removable cook wells, making my cleaning easy. Even though it is clear white, other NESCO MWR18-14 Roaster ovens have non-stick surfaces and won't make cleaning difficult.

Image Credits: whizz.co.ke

Like other roaster ovens, this 18 QT roaster has a programmable thermostat of up to 450 degrees and a red light that automatically turns off when the roaster is preheated. Though heavy, it can be carried with a little more effort to any place with big gatherings. I consider it one of the must-haves in my kitchen.

Pros:

  • Removable rack and enamel ease cleaning
  • The adjustable thermostat makes it easy to call for a variety of foods
  • Large cooking space

Cons:

  • It might be too heavy

4. HEYNEMO 24 Quart Electric Oven

Roaster Oven, 24Qt Electric Roaster Oven, Turkey...
  • 【Electric Roaster Oven】Multi-Function Electric Roaster Oven,...
  • 【Easy to Clean & Large Capacity】With cool-touch handle, it is...
  • 【Warming Setting】Warming setting keeps dinner at ideal...
  • 【Powerful Functions】1450W with red light, full-range...
  • 【Warm Tips】With multiple temperature settings, you can choose...

An 18 QT oven can be enough for some families, but if you need a bigger space to cook your whole turkey with extra space, this HEYNEMO roaster oven is ideal. It will cook your whole turkey and your vegetable side dishes.

Image Credits: walmart.com

I'm not recommending this roaster oven for only its size. Additionally, its superb adjustable temperatures, with 14 different heat settings ranging from 150 to 450 degrees, make it suitable for various foods. It also has a large pan complemented with a domed self-basting lid to ensure the upper part of your food never touches the lid to stain it or lose its crispiness, as in the case of a roasted chicken.

Cleaning this roaster oven is not a hassle, even after making an enormous amount of food. It has a removable enamel-on steel roasting pan and a stainless steel rack that I easily slide into the dishwasher for easy clean-up. On the downside, handling and storing this 24-pound roaster oven is challenging, so I often have to ask for help handling it.

Pros:

  • Removable pan and rack
  • Maximum 450 degrees temperature
  • Self-basting lid

Cons:

  • Quite heavy

5. NutriChef Convection Countertop Toaster Oven

NutriChef Convection Countertop Toaster Oven - Healthy...
  • BEST APPLIANCE FOR EASY ACCESS: Small enough to fit on your...
  • HEALTHY MEAL PREP: Healthy cooking made easy Temperature &...
  • FASTER MEALS: The best countertop convection oven for a faster...
  • EFFECTIVE & EVEN COOKING: High temperatures & built-in fan...
  • HASSLE FREE & CONVENIENT: Attractive glass makes for convenient...

This best countertop convection oven is designed to produce succulent meat steaks, chicken, vegetables, and much more. It cooks up to 50 % faster and better than the conventional oven with less electricity. Additionally, it cooks food thoroughly but leaves it flavorful and perfectly moist. Another add-on that leaves me with the highest level of satisfaction is its cooking technology, which leaves my food evenly cooked.

Image Credits: pricepulse.app

Unlike other roaster ovens, I don't have to add oil to my food because of the oven's temperature and time-setting adjustable air fryer, which leaves moisture and juices on the inside hence very healthy cooking. Moreover, its inbuilt fan distributes heat evenly, maintaining highly effective cooking and avoiding cold spots or burnt edges on your food.

This versatile oven can be an alternative to your kitchen's cooking appliance because it can cook, bake, steam, roast, broil, and air fry. It has a convenient tabletop design with a removable lid, making it easy to clean. In addition, the heat-resistant glass cooking bowl makes this oven a hassle-free electronic cooker.

Pros:

  • Capable of handling a variety of cooking types
  • Cooks evenly and effectively
  • Cooks faster
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Small compared to other ovens
  • Delicate glass cooking bowl

6. NESCO 4816-14 Porcelain Roaster Oven 6 Quarts

Sale
Nesco 4816-14 Porcelain Roaster Oven, 6 quart, White
  • 750-Watt heating base for moist, even cooking
  • Removable 6 quart cook well serves up to 6 people
  • Full-range temperature control (200°f - 450°f)
  • Durable porcelain enamel finish
  • Stay cool side handles

If you are worried about how to operate a roaster oven, this is the machine for you. It comes packaged with a recipe guide and user manual to ease the stress. I can cook, roast, bake, steam, slow cook, and serve with this oven. These services are numerous for one device, but luckily, this NESCO roaster oven does them all efficiently. 

Image Credits: malls-7.gq

NESCO 4816-14 porcelain roaster oven has a 750-watt heating range for moist and even cooking with 6 removable cook wells serving up to six people. It is durable because of the porcelain enamel finish. It also has a roasting rack with lift-out handles, making cleaning and oil-free roasting easy. Additionally, its side handles stay cool even during cooking, making it easy for you to hold them during and after.

Its automatic temperature control and self-basting dome cover maintains even cooking. Moreover, it has a double porcelain enamel finish that is easy to clean. It is also versatile, and suitable for preparing family meals

Pros:

  • Durable finish
  • Serves up to 6 people
  • Adjustable temperature

Cons:

  • Heavy
  • Can be pricy
  • Suitable for small family meals

7. EaZy BrandZ EZO Oberdome Plus

EaZy BrandZ EZO-3016R Oberdome, Plus, Red
  • Patented Large oberdome with Beautiful gloss outer finish and...
  • Revolutionary domelok Heat Technology cooks up to 51% faster than...
  • The oberdome can Bake a 12" Pizza, 2-chickens, Breads, Cakes,...
  • Saves energy, only 1150 watts and preheats in less than 6...
  • Easy to clean and weighs less than 8 pounds.

This Oberdome roaster design looks quite different from the others, but still, it will give you services the same as other roaster ovens, maintaining the flavor of your foods and giving you a perfect finish.

Image Credits: cayman.desert.com

Have you ever imagined how the up-scale hotel room meal services seem perfect with silver cloches like this roaster oven? That's how it works too. All you do is place your food on the roasting pan, fit your lid over, and set the right temperatures for your cooking or roasting.

The lid's heating temperature ranges up to 450 degrees, just as high as the traditional oven. During one of my camping events, I carried it along and was so amazed by its capability to cook, bake and roast just about every food I desired to take. It is also very portable and easy to clean, all thanks to its simple design.

If you are of the idea of making small pizzas and cakes on your countertop, this is the ideal appliance for you. However, it lacks some features that are quite advantageous to the other roaster ovens, like the self-basting lid and removable roasting pan

Pros:

  • Portable
  • Versatile
  • Fit for small family meals
  • Has a removable steel rack

Cons:

  • No self-basting lid
  • No removable roasting pan
  • It might be too small

8. Bella 24 Pound Turkey Roaster Oven

BELLA 18 Quart Turkey Roaster Oven with Roasting Rack,...
  • Cook up to a 22 lbs bird in this roaster. You can also bake or...
  • Adjustable thermostat control lets you select a temperature...
  • Cool touch handles allows you to transport your fully cooked bird...
  • Inner roasting pan is non-stick and completely removable making...
  • Includes a metal roasting rack that can double as cooling rack

Bella 24 turkey roaster comprises features just like other roaster ovens. It has a variable temperature control system that I can regulate to suit any cooking and food I want. Its big volume that can hold up to 24lb turkey and its durability are some of the qualities I've found to match my standards.

Image Credits: bellahousewares.com

Moreover, I could clean and maintain this 18-quart roaster due to its detachable parts that I can easily slide into a dishwasher. Besides the whole 24pound turkey, you can still fit some side dishes into this roaster and cook. This has proven to be time and energy-saving on my side.

Additionally, this oven has a compact design with handles that eases and secures its handling and storage. It also has a metal cooking rack that provides me with easy food removal. But just like any other electronic machine with faults, the temperatures might be off at times though it is a rare case.

The detachable cord allows you to keep your food warm for longer and serve it right out the roaster, so don't mind carrying it to big gatherings as a second oven because it will serve you just right.

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Durable
  • Great value for your money
  • It has a big capacity of up to 24 pound

Cons:

  • Temperature adjustments can be off sometimes

Factors to Consider When Choosing Roaster Oven

Image Credits: thespruceeats.com

When choosing the best electric roaster oven, it should tick all the boxes of power, purpose, size, temperature range, and other important factors listed below.

a) Purpose

The purpose of buying a roaster oven should be of great concern. It is advantageous to buy a multipurpose oven. After all, this will save you money and time.

b) Size and Capacity

Roaster ovens can be used to prepare various dishes when needed; hence, size is important when buying one. Buying a bigger one of 24 quarts doesn't harm, but storage space may be a hindrance. Alternatively, 16 to 22 quarts ovens are still big enough to serve up to 8 people.

Similarly, a family of 2 to 3 will not see the essence of buying the bigger ovens. Roaster ovens of 6 quarts are just a perfect option here.

c) Material

The most common materials for roaster ovens are enamel steel and stainless steel. Both are dishwasher safe, easy to clean, and have good heat retention abilities. The only difference, however, is weight. Stainless steel weighs less compared to enamel steel making its handling easier. But if you don't mind the heavy weight of the enamel steel, it is still a good choice that maximizes energy efficiency.

d) Lid

The lid is always made of the same material as the roasting pan. The only difference is their designs. High-domed lids allow you to fit your meat and roast without contacting the lid. A small window is another advantage that allows you to monitor your roasting without necessarily opening the removable lid and losing heat in the process. Also, consider the self-basting lid for its ability to recirculate moisture keeping your meat moist.

e) Temperature Ranges

Avoid roaster ovens with on and off dials because they don't offer the precision cooking you may need for your meals. Instead, a greater temperature range of up to 450 degrees with a good number of settings will allow you to do much more with your appliance. But most importantly, prioritize the settings that you will use most.

f) Controls and Interface

Almost all roaster ovens feature a small dial screen to enable you to set your temperature and cook settings. But a very important feature to look for is the heat indicator light, which is always red. This indicator light will help you know when the oven is hot, and it's also an easy way of keeping track of your food, so it doesn't get burnt.

g) Portability

It is a good idea to go for a roaster oven that you are comfortable carrying, not necessarily for outdoor but for storage and handling purposes.

h) Cleaning and Maintenance

The roaster oven material determines cleaning and maintenance. Most importantly, consider roaster oven with removable parts like a lid rack and roasting pan that are non-stick and dishwasher safe. The smooth surface of enamel steel is a good choice for easy cleanup.

i) Price

Generally, roaster ovens are cost-effective with better services compared to conventional ovens. However, avoid cheaper roaster ovens because they are made of inferior materials that will break down sooner after a few uses and can burn your food.

Benefits of Buying a Roaster Oven

Image Credits: ubuy.ke

1. When preparing multiple dishes, a roaster oven is a great tool because it offers extra space; however, there are some qualities like speed and energy saving that it performs better than a conventional oven.

2. Their small sizes and even heat distribution make them energy efficient.

3. Roaster ovens are completely sealed; hence if your goal is to retain the juices and moisture in your meat without adding extra water or oil, it is a great choice.

4. Electric roaster ovens cut cooking time because their smaller cooking space heats up quickly.

5. The removable roasting rack, pan, and lid help cut on cleaning time because you can easily throw them in the dishwasher, and you are done.

6. As for their sizes, it is easy to transport them, and most importantly, they best fit into smaller households.

7. It is versatile. It can cook, bake, roast and steam and can slow cook.

Conclusion

Buying a roaster oven should not be a hassle. Neither should it be a go-and-pick procedure. Instead, invest in roaster ovens that are worth the price and fit the purpose for which you buy them. Several designs and sizes would suit your cooking options anytime, anywhere.

Featured Image Credit:pinterest.com

Ian Mutuli

About the author

Ian Mutuli

Founder and Managing Editor of Archute. He is also a graduate architect from The University of Nairobi, Kenya.